Appeals court rules ROSS copying of Westlaw was not fair use | Coral Wire
Daily news for authors · with CoralGet the brief
Legal · Sun, Oct 4 2026 · Coral Index 58/100

Appeals court rules ROSS copying of Westlaw was not fair use

It is the first time an appeals court has rejected an AI company's fair use defense for unauthorized copying of this kind

Appeals court rules ROSS copying of Westlaw was not fair use
Image generated for this story · Coral Wire

Here's a sentence you don't get to write often in this business: an appeals court looked at an AI company's fair use defense and said, flatly, no.

The case is Thomson Reuters v. ROSS, and it's been grinding through the courts since May 2020, when Thomson Reuters sued after ROSS used its Westlaw headnotes to train an AI legal research platform. The district court in Delaware sided with Thomson Reuters. ROSS appealed. The Third Circuit just affirmed — and in doing so, became the first appeals court to rule that this kind of unauthorized copying by an AI company is not protected by fair use.

That "first" matters more than any single headnote dispute. Fair use arguments from AI companies have leaned hard on the idea that training data markets don't really exist yet — that nobody's losing money because nobody was ever going to get paid for this in the first place. The Third Circuit didn't buy it. The court noted that the licensing market for AI training is, in its words, "rapidly developing." That's not a stray observation. It was part of the court's market-harm analysis, in a ruling that turned on ROSS building a direct competitor to Westlaw, and it's the line AAP CEO Maria Pallante called out directly, saying the decision "supports the premise that a robust licensing market among developers and rightsholders is essential to achieving sustainable and ethical progress in AI technology."

Authors Guild CEO Mary Rasenberger put it in plainer terms: the ruling "vindicates copyright law" and "clarifies that one cannot steal someone else's works to train an AI system that displaces the very works the AI was trained on." She's right that this cuts at something specific — AI companies "try to minimize or flatly deny" that a licensing market exists in their fair use arguments, and now there's appellate precedent saying otherwise.

What this means for you: the court recognized a licensing market for AI training data, and publishers and rightsholders are likely to lean on that in licensing negotiations and pending cases. But ROSS was a non-generative legal search tool built to compete with Westlaw, and the ruling does not decide whether training a generative AI model on books is fair use. It's not your case and it's not your payout.

This week, do two things. First, if you've gotten any licensing inquiry or notice about AI training use of your work, don't let it sit in your inbox — this ruling just made those conversations worth having. Second, watch for the Authors Guild's next statement on how this precedent applies beyond the legal-research niche ROSS operated in. The language here — "rapidly developing" licensing market — is about to show up in a lot of other briefs. Make sure it shows up in arguments made on your behalf, too.

Correction, 7 October 2026: An earlier version of this story said the court's licensing-market remark was the hinge the whole ruling turned on and called the decision the "strongest legal precedent yet" and "the teeth" for authors' AI training claims. The ruling turned on ROSS building a direct competitor to Westlaw with a non-generative search tool, and it does not decide whether training generative AI on books is fair use. We have corrected the story.

From the Coral Wire edition of Sun, Oct 4 2026 · Coral Index 58/100 (Tailwinds building)

Coverage — 2 sources

Every outlet found reporting this story.

Spot something wrong?

Every story here links its sources so you can check them. If we have got a fact, a figure or a date wrong, tell us and we will correct the page and say so on it.

Prefer email? info@coralwire.ai

◆ The Daily Brief

Get the wire in your inbox

One short email each morning with the day’s news that actually moves your author business. Free, from the same desk.

From the Coral Hart group

Write it, plan it, launch it