Appeals court hands Thomson Reuters a landmark AI training win | Coral Wire
Daily news for authors · with CoralGet the brief
Legal · Fri, Oct 2 2026 · Coral Index 58/100

Appeals court hands Thomson Reuters a landmark AI training win

The court rejected Ross Intelligence's fair use defense, but stressed that the case does not involve generative AI, which may limit its reach

Appeals court hands Thomson Reuters a landmark AI training win
Image generated for this story · Coral Wire

A legal research company trained its AI on a competitor's database. That competitor sued. And this week, five years later, a federal appeals court said: no, that wasn't fair use.

The case is Thomson Reuters v. Ross Intelligence, and the facts are almost quaint by today's AI standards. Back in 2020, Thomson Reuters accused Ross Intelligence of copying material from its Westlaw platform to train a competing legal search engine. Ross argued it was fair use — the same defense every AI company sued over training data has leaned on since. On Tuesday, a U.S. appeals court rejected that argument and upheld the ruling for Thomson Reuters. Reuters itself called it "a first-of-its-kind ruling by a U.S. appeals court in a wave of high-stakes copyright cases over AI training." Judge Tamika Montgomery-Reeves wrote that Thomson Reuters's materials possess "a creative spark," and that Ross "aspired to be a direct competitor by using them for a highly similar purpose." She also noted that the case does not concern a large language model or other generative AI tool, which may limit its impact on other AI copyright cases.

Here's the part that should sting more than the ruling itself: Ross Intelligence isn't around to appeal, celebrate, or regroup. The company announced in December 2020 that it was shutting down its platform the following month, citing the cost of litigation. It tried to fight back with antitrust claims, accusing Thomson Reuters of illegally tying Westlaw's search tools to its case law database. A federal judge dismissed those claims in September 2024, ending that counterclaim. So by the time this appeals court ruling landed, the defendant had been gone for nearly five years. The win is almost entirely symbolic now — except that symbols are exactly what shape the next ruling.

And there are a lot of next rulings coming. PYMNTS reported in July that courts have split on where AI liability actually starts, and more cases are pending through 2026. This Thomson Reuters decision doesn't settle that split — but it's now a data point every judge, plaintiff, and AI company's lawyer will have to reckon with.

For authors, here's the stake. But be careful about what it covers. The court stressed that this case does not involve a large language model or other generative AI: Ross's tool retrieved existing passages rather than generating original text. In Bartz v. Anthropic, a judge ruled that training Claude on published books was fair use. So this ruling does not settle whether training a model on books is infringement.

What to do this week: if you're part of any pending author-AI litigation or considering joining one, flag this ruling to your counsel or your Guild rep now. It's the first appellate precedent of its kind, and precedent is the thing lawyers build arguments on. The opinion is published, so ask what it means for your case today.

Correction, 7 October 2026: An earlier version of this story said the court's reasoning was sealed and that the ruling strengthens claims against companies that trained large language models on books. The opinion is published, and the judge stressed that the case does not involve a large language model or other generative AI and that this may limit its impact on other AI copyright cases. We have corrected the story.

From the Coral Wire edition of Fri, Oct 2 2026 · Coral Index 58/100 (Tailwinds building)

Coverage — 2 sources

Every outlet found reporting this story.

Spot something wrong?

Every story here links its sources so you can check them. If we have got a fact, a figure or a date wrong, tell us and we will correct the page and say so on it.

Prefer email? info@coralwire.ai

◆ The Daily Brief

Get the wire in your inbox

One short email each morning with the day’s news that actually moves your author business. Free, from the same desk.

From the Coral Hart group

Write it, plan it, launch it