Third Circuit rules AI training on Westlaw headnotes infringed copyright
The appeals court found ROSS Intelligence's use of 2,243 Thomson Reuters headnotes was not fair use, the only Circuit ruling so far on AI training.

On September 29, 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled in Thomson Reuters v ROSS Intelligence, a case filed in 2020, according to The Scholarly Kitchen. The outlet reported it is the only Circuit Court decision in the US to address AI training to date. ROSS had copied Thomson Reuters' Westlaw legal database after being denied a license, in order to build a competing AI legal search engine, and appealed after Thomson Reuters won summary judgment, challenging both the copyrightability of the copied material and ROSS's fair use defense.
The court held that all 2,243 independently created headnotes at issue had "some creative spark," per the ruling as quoted by the outlet, because Thomson Reuters' editors made creative decisions about which points of law to include and how to word them. Having found the headnotes protected, the court then rejected ROSS's fair use defense, finding the use "minimally transformative, at best," reasoning that both companies used the headnotes to build legal-research platforms serving the same purpose.
This is the first time a US Circuit Court has actually ruled on AI training, not just speculated about it, and it came down firmly for the copyright owner. If you publish anything with editorial structure, headnotes, abstracts, curated summaries, pay attention to the court's reasoning: creative selection and wording can earn protection even when the underlying facts can't. The "transformative use" argument that AI companies lean on hardest just took a direct hit, since the court called ROSS's use "minimally transformative, at best."
From the Coral Wire edition of Sat, Nov 21 2026 · Coral Index 67/100 (Tailwinds building)