Judge lets four counts of Trump's PRH defamation suit proceed
Judge Merryday dismissed two counts but ruled four may go to trial, questioning whether the Lucky Loser authors sought enough expert guidance.

Judge Merryday ruled that four counts of Donald Trump's defamation case against Penguin Random House, the New York Times, and Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, authors of the book Lucky Loser, may proceed to trial, Publishers Marketplace reported. Two other counts were dismissed.
The decision turned on the meaning of "actual malice" as defined in the precedent-setting case New York Times Co., according to the outlet. Merryday's ruling also questions whether Buettner and Craig sought out sufficient guidance from experts in their analysis of Trump's financial doings.
This one belongs on your watchlist, not your worry list, but watch it closely. A federal judge just let the bulk of a defamation case against a Big Five publisher move toward trial, and part of the reasoning singles out whether the authors leaned on enough outside experts when they dug into Trump's finances. That's a question about sourcing practice, and sourcing practice is something every nonfiction author can control.
From the Coral Wire edition of Sat, Nov 21 2026 · Coral Index 67/100 (Tailwinds building)