Lawyer proposes split terms for search versus AI content use
Tim Cowen wants crawlers free to index for search but required to ask permission and pay for other uses of website material.

Tim Cowen, chair of the antitrust practice at Preiskel & Co LLP and co-founder of the Movement for an Open Web, told Competition Policy International that publishers' dependence on platforms like Meta for audience access undermines their ability to refuse content terms, raising a competition issue alongside copyright and contract disputes, according to the outlet.
Cowen proposed separate terms for search indexing versus other uses of website material: crawlers could index for search without charge, but would need permission and would owe payment for anything beyond that, using robots.txt alongside contractual terms to signal conditions. He said this contract approach is being implemented through publishers and trade associations, with claims moving through the courts.
Cowen said the Competition and Markets Authority's inquiry into Meta's terms reaches beyond the company's recent revisions, which removed references to training, narrowed provisions to advertising and business products, and postponed implementation. He also cited Getty Images' dispute with Stability AI and the Like Company proceedings involving Google as examples of the jurisdictional and legal difficulties publishers face in asserting rights over content use.
Here's the part worth sitting with: Cowen's argument isn't really about copyright law, it's about leverage. If a platform controls whether readers find you, you don't get to say no to its terms — you just get to comply. His fix, free indexing but paid permission for everything else via robots.txt plus contract terms, is still a proposal, not a rule anyone has to follow yet. Watch whether the Competition and Markets Authority's inquiry into Meta's terms turns this from an idea into something with teeth.
From the Coral Wire edition of Fri, Nov 20 2026 · Coral Index 62/100 (Tailwinds building)