Judge orders artist plaintiffs to detail income, not tax returns
Magistrate Judge Cisneros wants source-by-source art income from 2020 through 2025, answered by narrative, not by handing over records.

Magistrate Judge Cisneros ruled on a discovery dispute in the copyright suit brought by Sarah Andersen and other visual artists, granting defendants' request for financial information from the plaintiffs while rejecting their request for the plaintiffs' tax returns.
In place of tax returns, the order requires plaintiffs to provide a supplemental narrative response to an interrogatory, rather than citing records under Rule 33(d). According to the order, plaintiffs' responses must specify income earned source by source for all art-related income from January 1, 2020 through 2025, broken down by month, quarter, or year — whichever increment is shortest and feasible to calculate — and each plaintiff must also describe the full scope of their art-related income for that period.
Here's the trade the defense actually got: no tax returns, but a far more exposing ask. A narrative breakdown of every dollar of art income, source by source, month by month if you can manage it, for five straight years. That's not paperwork you dig out of a drawer — it's homework, and it's due on their timeline. If you're a plaintiff in this case, start reconstructing those numbers now, because "I'll find it later" isn't an answer a court order accepts.
From the Coral Wire edition of Wed, Nov 18 2026 · Coral Index 69/100 (Tailwinds building)